patient refund laws in virginia

Add your voice now to help CMA explain why we must improve access for Medi-Cal beneficiaries in a sustainable manner. As California continues its efforts to vaccinate all eligible residents against COVID-19, the state is offering additio As part of its policy-making process, the California Medical Association (CMA) allows members to submit resolutions for Physicians and physician groups affected by the COVID-19 pandemic have until March 3, 2023, to apply for a 2022 Medicar Santa Cruz Public Health Officer Gail Newel, M.D., recently announced she would be retiringfor the second timeafter s PHC recently announcedalmost $25,000 in MedStudentsServe awards across the state to support medical student projects t Attendees will hear directly from our physicians in the state legislature about the states priorities for health acces PHC has partnered with CA Quits to provide free tobacco cessation resources and learning opportunities. If you receive a payment from an insurance carrier . What does it mean to identify an overpayment? This is going to be based on the median in-network contracted rate for the same or similar service in the same or similar geographic area. Here are three best practices for refunds in healthcare payments. Assuming that a physician has determined that an overpayment has been made, another important question is to whom and how is a payment returned. If you identify other laws or additional subject matter that you think would be helpful to include, or if you have any comments or questions about this document, please contact Pat Devine, Jon Joseph, Jamie Baskerville Martin, or Braxton McKee. Similarly, insurance companies that are found to engage in a pattern of violations of the new law are subject to fines or other remedies by the SCC. Updates to the data set in subsequent years will be based on data collected in 2020 that delineates between paid claims in-network versus out-of-network and adjusted by the Medical CPI for every year thereafter. There is an exception: If the patient is enrolled in a high-deductible health plan with a health savings account or other plan that prohibits payment for first-dollar coverage prior to the enrollee meeting the deductible. New Law Protects Virginia Patients, Families from Surprise Medical Bills July 28, 2020 Pressroom FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Julian Walker Jeff Kelley VHHA VACEP (804) 304-7402 (804) 397-9700 jtwalker@vhha.com jeff@kelleyus.com Multi-Year Effort Produces New State Law that Protects Virginia Patients and Families from Expensive Surprise Medical Bills The most efficient way for staff to issue a refund is the one-click method. . I am proud we were able to come together in Virginia to pass a solution that takes patients out of the middle, ensures health care providers are reimbursed for the care they provide, and protects Virginia families. You should be able to easily manage users within your system to assign refund rights to the staff member(s) who will be responsible for handling refunds. authorizing the disclosure of medical records related to subdivisions 1 through 4 [see above] . Written procedures to implement the policies shall ensure that each patient is: 1. 54.1-2902 (Unlawful to practice without license) Prescribing Drugs to Bona Fide Patients Va. Code Ann. Opt in to receive updates on the latest health care news, legislation, and more. When you receive the written request for the overpayment, attach a check for the overpayment to the request and send it to the address indicated on the request. Four, For patient overpayments: HIPPA requires these payments to be returned within 60 days of identification. Day 100: Both parties must make written submissions in support of final offer. f. Whether it is the payer or patient that receives the refund. . If the health plan and provider or facility cannot agree on what is a commercially reasonable amount to be paid for the service after 30 days, either party will have 10 days to elect to have the dispute settled by arbitration. . Careful review and investigation may be necessary to determine whether an overpayment exists. We hope that this list of health care laws will grow and develop over time through the input of its users. The refund shall be made as follows: (1) If the patient requests a refund, within 30 days following the request from that patient for a refund if the duplicate payment has been received, or within 30 days of receipt of the duplicate payment if the duplicate payment has not been received. In short, there are many ways for physicians and their staff to make mistakes in billing that would mean that they were not entitled to receive payment. If you are unable to refund all patients at one time plan a schedule for completion. Estate Planning Attorney in Nevada City, CA Website (866) 684-7169 Message Offers FREE consultation! Except in the following circumstances, minors must have their parents or guardians permission before they can access their record: One of the most difficult problems that physicians and other providers face is determining when the 60 day time limit is triggered. Because of the complexities of reimbursement and the myriad statutes and regulations regulating the health care industry, physicians and other providers must be alert to this duty and handle allegations of overpayment carefully including the reporting of the overpayment. Customer Returns and Refunds Under Federal Law Many retailers, as part of their business models, allow returns if customers change their minds or receive unwanted items as gifts. (a) If an overpayment determination is the result of retroactive review or audit of coverage decisions or payment levels not related to fraud, a health insurer shall adhere to the following procedures: 1. Virginia Statutory Law: 32.1-127.1:03 , D,1 Providers may disclose records "pursuant to the written authorization of (i) the individual or (ii) in the case of a minor, (a) his custodial parent, guardian, or other person authorized to consent to treatment of minors pursuant to 54.1-2969, or (b) the minor himself, if he has consented to . The minor or his parent, either or both, shall have the right to have the denial reviewed as specified in subsection F of 32.1-127.1:03 to determine whether to make the minors health record available to the requesting parent. For patients with larger balances, set up a payment plan to collect the balance over time. HTML PDF: 84.69.050: Refund with respect to amounts paid state. A clean claim is defined in the balancing billing law similar to how clean claim is defined in the Fair Business Practices Act. A video of that event can be viewed here. ), this time frame can be exceeded. The data set includes the following amounts: The median allowed amount (combined in- and out-of-network) from 2019 and updated for 2021 using a Medical Consumer Price Index (CPI) adjustment. We will update this FAQ as more information becomes available. Refer to the official regulations, which can be found at the Missouri Secretary of States web site. First, providers may be limited to processing refunds during a specific billing cycle. The arbitration is baseball style meaning the arbitrator will determine the final payment amount the insurer or provider must accept by choosing one of the parties' best final offer. 6768). If more than one arbitrator remains, the SCC will choose the arbitrator. Day 115: Arbitrator issues decision. The balance billing law applies to all Virginia-regulated managed care plans and state employee health benefit plans. (3) Virginia State Agency Regulation 12VAC35-115-90 Form for recommending diagnosis examination A good way to establish controls over refunds at your organization is to limit the ability to offer refunds to just a few staff members. Section 54.1-2969 E of the Code of Virginia [see above] permits a minor to authorize the disclosure of information related to medical or health services for a sexually transmitted or contagious disease, family planning or pregnancy, and outpatient care, treatment or rehabilitation for substance use disorders, mental illness, or emotional disturbance. A more reasonable position may be that a providers 60 days is not triggered until the group has a reasonable time to investigate the facts and determine the amount of the overpayment if any. Are providers able to bundle claims for arbitration? medical records related to subdivisions 1 through 4 [above]. Compliance with the overpayment statute does not guarantee that the provider will not face other sanctions related to the overpayment when it is a serious violation. However, if the refund doesnt involve a duplicative payment from the payor and if the patient will be returning, the physician can suggest that the amount be applied as a credit toward the next visit. Parties are engaged in good faith negotiation. The California Medical Association (CMA) often receives questions from physician members regarding the amount of time that physicians have to refund monies owed to patients. Depending on the circumstances (fraud, etc. All claims for overpayment must be submitted to a provider within 30 months after the health insurer's payment of the claim. A clean claim is a claim that (i) has no material defect or impropriety, including any lack of any reasonably require substantiation documentation, that substantially prevents timely payment from being made on the claim; and (ii) that includes Internal Revenue Service (IRS) documentation required for the insurer to process payment. All refunds to be issued on a timely basis within 60 . Additionally, insurers are required to make information regarding the applicability of the balance billing law available to providers through electronic or other communications generally used by a provider to verify enrollee eligibility and benefits information. Parties in arbitration retain the ability to reach a settlement agreement during that process. (1) A qualifying patient shall pay a $40.00 fee for a new or renewal application. Subject person can review his/her medical and mental records; however, mental records; however, mental records may not be personally reviewed in physician feels review would be injurious to persons physical or mental health or well-being (2.2-3705); patient or attorney upon patient's written request to . When you put payment in the hands of your patients, they are more likely to pay close attention to how much they owe and for what. CMAhas published a guide to help physicians navigate the end of the states emergency authority. Each party can then veto up to two of the arbitrators. Posted on Jul 17, 2014 It depends on your situation. The facilities do not have to prove that they have . Virginia Hospital & Healthcare Association 2023 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved.Privacy StatementTerms of UseSite Map. They also cover refund checks that the practice has sent to a patient, but that the patient has not cashed, and other forms of credit balances. A. . (from APA Legal & Regulatory Affairs Staff), Federal Substance Abuse Statute & Regulations. 12VAC35-115-90, B, 5: See Also: . These regulations do not prohibit a program from refusing to provide treatment until the minor patient consents to the disclosure necessary to obtain reimbursement, but refusal to provide treatment may be prohibited under a State or local law requiring the program to furnish the service irrespective of ability to pay. . Medical or health services needed in the case of outpatient care, treatment or rehabilitation for substance abuse as defined in 37.2-100 ; or. . We talk a lot about what providers need to do to deliver a consumer-friendly healthcare payments experience to patients, including setting clear expectations upfront, offering new, digital payment options and eliminating paper wherever possible. Patient rights. If an overpayment does exist, the physician must return the money even if its a small amount. ACEP is the largest and most influential emergency medicine organization in the world. Unclaimed property (primary rule) first goes to the state of the patient's last known address. The radiologist performing the MRI is in-network. Virginia Passes Futile Care Law (February 2018) SB 222 and HB 226 have passed. Patient refunds are necessary when a patient has overpaid his or her portion of the claim. Insurance covers x amount after treatment filed. A patient goes to an out-of-network freestanding imaging center for an MRI of knee. We are greatly appreciative of legislative champions such as Senator Favola, Chairman Torian, and many other leaders who maintained the resolve to accomplish this important law change in the face of challenging hurdles over the course of several years.. It is the Affiliate's policy to refund all amounts due to patients. Copyright Center for Ethical Practice, 977 Seminole Trail, #312, Charlottesville, Virginia 22901 If a patient who has health insurance is treated by an out-of-network provider or facility for their healthcare needs, the provider or facility will submit the claim to the patients insurer. If there is an arbitration decided in favor of the provider, the insurer not the patient is required to pay the difference between initial amount and the good-faith negotiated amount or final offer amount approved by the arbitrator. Sellers are not required to have any specific type of return policy under Ohio law. The cardiac surgeon, anesthesiologist, CRNA, are in-network. The real problem is that determining whether an overpayment has been received probably involves complex reimbursement questions, which may be of a legal nature and involve significant factual questions that may both include reviewing medical records as well as interviewing staff and possibly patients. 54.1-2952 (Supervision of assistants) I, along with the entire MSV community, appreciate all of the hard work that went into making this bill a reality., We have always said this bill was not the best for doctors, hospitals, or insurance companies, but it is the best for patients. A parent may access his minor childs services record unless parental rights have been terminated, a court order provides otherwise, or the minors treating physician or clinical psychologist has determined, in the exercise of professional judgment, that the disclosure to the parent would be reasonably likely to cause substantial harm to the minor or another person. For serious violations that involve false claims or Stark violations, a provider may want to use the Office of Inspector Generals Self-Disclosure Protocol. Access by Minor : This prevents over-collecting, as your staff can track payments along the way. Thank you for your interest in InstaMed. "credit balances")whether due to claims processing errors or overbilling is a non-negotiable. The BOI interprets the law and regulations to require providers to provide patients with the entire notice of consumer rights each and every time any nonemergency service is scheduled, with the bill sent to the patient, and upon request. A BILL to amend the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended, by adding thereto a new section, designated 11-15-9t, relating to creating the Save the Hospitals Act; exempting nonprofit hospitals that provide a certain amount of uncompensated care from sales tax and requiring West Virginia Hospital Finance Authority to promulgate rules to The list of carrier provider networks must be updated on a regular basis. Welcome to the Virginia Law section of FindLaw's State Law collection. Once it has been determined that a refund to a patient is due, a request should be generated within thirty days (30) of the refund recognition. The law and balance billing prohibition apply to claims by the out-of-network vascular surgeon because the hospital is an in-network facility and the services being provided are surgical or ancillary services. Unless a patient specifically asks for a check, there is no reason you cant issue every refund electronically. Within your source system, staff should be able to access the patients payment receipt and, in one click, issue payment back onto the original payment method. Session Law 2019-191 updated and modernized several provisions of Chapter 90 that pertain to the Medical Board. A copy of the patient's rights shall be displayed in the hospice office for public review. Virginia Governor Ralph Northam presided over a virtual bill signing ceremony for the legislation last week that featured remarks from Senator Favola, Chairman Torian, House of Delegates Health, Welfare, and Institutions Committee Chairman Mark Sickles of Fairfax County, Senator George Barker of Fairfax County, and Virginia Health and Human Resources Secretary Dr. Dan Carey. One of the most important changes created by the Health Care Reform Act is the establishment of an explicit duty to refund Medicare and Medicaid overpayments within 60 days of identification. This new law is transformational. AUTHORIZATION FOR DISCLOSURE OF RECORDS: (Outpatient Mental Health, Substance Abuse, Family Planning, Pregnancy). Within 30 days of that, the physician must refund the overpaid amount. Jim Justice called it a "Proud day for me." The law is set to take effect in July 2024. Day 0: Out-of-network provider submits clean claim to carrier/payer. If the patient's address is unknown, (secondary rule) the right to the money goes to the state where your practice is located. We know that most patients do not like to use checks to pay their healthcare bills. 23-17-19.1 Rights of patients. Day 70: Carrier/payer or provider can request arbitration by sending the SCCs arbitration form to the SCC and to the non-initiatingparty. Virginia code requires businesses to conspicuously post its policy or customers can return items within 20 days of purchase. B. (2) The application of a qualifying patient who fails to submit the required $40.00 fee is considered incomplete and shall be denied. VACEP | 14321 Winter Breeze Drive, Suite 345 | Midlothian, VA 23113. Medicaid - In general, Medicaid may request refunds for up to five years. During the procedure, however, a complication occurs, and a consultation is required by a vascular surgeon. Patient Refunds or CreditsMost Refunds will not generate and cannot be refunded until after insurance pays. How a provider handles the refund process will influence the patients overall impression of their healthcare experience. What does the arbitration timeline look like? A. The means of access and format of this information will likely vary by insurer. The Center is solely responsible for all aspects of the programs. You will need to send a letter to the patient's last known address advising them of the credit amount. Business & Professions Code 732 states that if the patient has not requested the refund within 90 days of the date when the physician discovers, or should have discovered, the receipt of the overpayment, the physician must notify the patient of the overpayment. Please join us for the next installment of our monthly Virtual Grand Grounds COVID-19 Therapeutics:- When and How to DHCS recently announced the list of drugs that will require prior-authorization (PA) under Phase II Wave 2 of the Med CMAhas partnered with CHHS to develop the CMA Data Exchange Explainer Series. California does not enforce a maximum home equity value limit.) What happens if a patient overpays a provider? The Virginia Department of Planning & Budget has designed a Regulatory Town Hall for anyone interested in the proposal of regulations or meetings of regulatory boards.. Duty to Report Adult or Child Abuse, Neglect or Exploitation. We expect that in most instances, this will be the insurers in-network amount. This commonly means a resident will be discharged to their home, the home of loved one, or an assisted living residence. Allowed amount is the sum of the amount paid by the payer and enrollee cost-sharing. 4) The resident's presence in the nursing home jeopardizes the health of other residents. Some of the most common reasons for overpayment include: When overpayment occurs in healthcare, providers find themselves in the business of issuing refunds. ( 2022 Medicaid income and resource standards set the limit in most states at $636,000, but some have increased this limit to $955,000. A public comment period on the draft regulations is open through September 1, 2020, and the proposed effective date for the regulations is January 1, 2021. Recently, draft regulations related to implementation of the new balance billing law have been made public by the SCC. However, the BOI interprets the law to mean that provider groups composed of one or more health care professionals billing under a single Tax Identification Number are not permitted to bundle claims for arbitration if the health care professional providing the service is not the same. Does the 60 day clock start when a report is received by one physician that another physician in the group has improperly billed for evaluation and management of a particular patient? Receipts for refunds should be accessible to both staff and patients through a simple search. You will need a working knowledge of each. Refunds also shouldnt have to disrupt staffs workflow by introducing a manual step into their process; refunds should post back into your source system in real-time, so no one has to go through the manual work of making sure the balance is correct. False claims, of course, can be the subject of qui tam lawsuits, government investigations, MAC/RAC audits, among others, and, if liability is found, then damages can be assessed at three times the amount of the claim and civil monetary penalties. A health care facility is also required to provide the notice of consumer rights with any bill for an emergency service. Licensure Regulations Manual Chapter 198 RSMo (updated August 28, 2022) Law of Georgia No 3379 of 20 March 2015 - website, 31.3.2015 Article 18 1. B. Healthcare payments are complex, making it hard to determine the exact amount a patient will owe. (h) If a patient overpays a physician, the physician must refund the amount of the overpayment not later than the 30th day after the date the physician determines that an overpayment has been made. If the provider or facility and insurer do not agree to what is a commercially reasonable amount, then an arbitration process is available to resolve disputes. Unless there is a state law to the contrary, although non-payment is a valid reason to terminate a patient, a patient cannot be refused care while still in the . Typically, the only IRS documentation that is required for an insurer to process claims is IRS Form W-9. Applies to all Virginia-regulated managed care plans and state employee health benefit plans out-of-network freestanding imaging center an... Records related to subdivisions 1 through 4 [ above ] patients at one time a... Are three best practices for refunds should be accessible to Both staff and patients through a search... & Co. all rights reserved.Privacy StatementTerms of UseSite Map or rehabilitation for Substance Abuse Statute & regulations refunds in payments. To five years public review medicine organization in the hospice Office for public review Abuse Statute regulations! The way your staff can track payments along the way the medical.! Have to prove that they have home of loved one, or an assisted living residence section FindLaw. Of its users care plans and state employee health benefit plans payment plan to collect the balance billing law been. Emergency service review and investigation may patient refund laws in virginia necessary to determine the exact amount a specifically. Statute & regulations type of return policy under Ohio law ) the &! Balances & quot ; ) whether due to patients best practices for refunds in healthcare payments are complex, it! & Regulatory Affairs staff ), Federal Substance Abuse, Family Planning, Pregnancy ) on! In Nevada City, CA Website ( 866 ) 684-7169 Message Offers consultation! Authorizing the disclosure of medical records related to implementation of the new billing. 2018 ) SB 222 and HB 226 have passed ( February 2018 ) SB 222 and 226... Payment from an insurance carrier the end of the patient & # x27 ; s last known address and... Through the input of its users will likely vary by insurer FREE consultation there is reason. Acep is the sum of the amount paid by the payer or patient that the. No reason you cant issue every refund electronically this FAQ as more information becomes available center for an MRI knee! Limited to processing refunds during a specific billing cycle of Chapter 90 that pertain the! You are unable to refund all amounts due to patients s presence in the case outpatient! Claim is defined in 37.2-100 ; or health benefit plans your situation ( 866 ) 684-7169 Message FREE!: carrier/payer or provider can request arbitration by sending the SCCs arbitration form the! A new or renewal application you are unable to patient refund laws in virginia all amounts due patients! Found at the Missouri Secretary of States web site of identification is: 1 Code. Process claims is IRS form W-9 Minor: this prevents over-collecting, as your staff can track payments along way... Virginia Hospital & healthcare Association 2023 JPMorgan Chase & Co. all rights reserved.Privacy StatementTerms of UseSite Map,. Parties in arbitration retain the ability to reach a settlement agreement during that process recently, draft related. Settlement agreement during that process the official regulations, which can be at! The patient & # x27 ; s last known address advising them of the programs provider can request by... Claims is IRS form W-9 SCC and to the non-initiatingparty means a will. The nursing home jeopardizes the health of other residents for completion, which can be viewed here Prescribing Drugs Bona... Acep is the largest and most influential emergency medicine organization in the balancing billing law applies to all managed... Office for public review presence in the nursing home jeopardizes the health of other residents refunds will not and... Receive a payment plan to collect the balance over time one, or an assisted residence! Public by the payer and enrollee cost-sharing cant issue every refund electronically healthcare payments complex! Abuse, Family Planning, Pregnancy ) MRI of knee are not required to have any type. Handles the refund return the money even if its a small amount payer or patient that the! Affiliate & # x27 ; s last known address advising them of the States emergency.. Law section of FindLaw & # x27 ; s policy to refund all patients one! & Regulatory Affairs staff ), Federal Substance Abuse as defined in the nursing home jeopardizes the health other... Commonly means a resident will be the insurers in-network amount Planning Attorney in Nevada City CA. Of the amount paid by the SCC and to the official regulations, which can be viewed here to. Each party can then veto up to two of the arbitrators: Both parties must make submissions! Exist, the home of loved one, or an assisted living residence for public review news,,... Aspects of the credit amount how a provider may want to use the Office of Inspector Generals Self-Disclosure.! ) Prescribing Drugs to patient refund laws in virginia Fide patients Va. Code Ann [ see ]... State of the patient & # x27 ; s last known address advising them of the credit amount of. Care facility is Also required to provide the notice of consumer rights with any bill for an emergency.... Qualifying patient shall pay a $ 40.00 fee for a check, is! Have to prove that they have address advising them of the programs now to physicians... Instances, this will be discharged to their home, the physician must the... Be necessary to determine the exact amount a patient goes to an out-of-network freestanding center. Statute & regulations to their home, the home of loved one, or assisted! Determine whether an overpayment exists a vascular surgeon of other residents care plans and state employee benefit! Even if its a small amount patients Va. Code Ann one arbitrator remains, the physician must refund overpaid! That this list of health care facility is Also required to provide the notice of consumer rights with any for. Processing refunds during a specific billing cycle and develop over time through the input of its users Futile law... Depends on your situation of this information will likely vary by insurer three best practices for refunds in payments! You receive a payment from an insurance carrier 17, 2014 it depends on your situation to! Depends on your situation party can then veto up to five years if more than arbitrator... Will choose the arbitrator over time the end of the amount paid the! Involve false claims or Stark violations, a provider handles the refund process will the. Association 2023 JPMorgan Chase & Co. all rights reserved.Privacy StatementTerms of UseSite Map false claims or Stark,. By patient refund laws in virginia: this prevents over-collecting, as your staff can track along... Or rehabilitation for Substance Abuse, Family Planning, Pregnancy ) updated and modernized several provisions Chapter... Policy or customers can return items within 20 days of that event can be at... Acep is the largest and most influential emergency medicine organization in the balancing billing similar. Letter to the official regulations, which can be viewed here provider can request by. ) SB 222 and HB 226 have passed however, a complication occurs, and a consultation is required a. With larger balances, set up a payment plan to collect the over. Hospice Office for public review items within 20 days of that, the physician must return the even! ; credit balances & quot ; ) whether due to patients in Nevada City, Website... Fair Business practices Act Office for public review insurance carrier it is the payer or patient that receives refund. Determine whether an overpayment exists a patient refund laws in virginia agreement during that process VA 23113 four, for patient overpayments: requires... Of UseSite Map - in general, medicaid may request refunds for up to years... Insurance pays made public by the SCC and to the medical Board be... Be returned within 60 and enrollee cost-sharing & healthcare Association 2023 JPMorgan Chase & Co. all rights reserved.Privacy of! Prevents over-collecting, as your staff can track payments along the way generate and can be. Time through the input of its users even if its a small amount a simple search not enforce maximum... Post its policy or customers can return items within 20 days of identification cant! Pregnancy ) Attorney in Nevada City, CA Website ( 866 ) 684-7169 Offers. Arbitration form to the virginia law section of FindLaw & # x27 s... Should be accessible to Both staff and patients through a simple search refunds will generate! To Bona Fide patients Va. Code Ann ( 1 ) a qualifying patient shall a... The facilities do not like to use the Office of Inspector Generals Self-Disclosure Protocol records related to subdivisions 1 4... Maximum home equity value limit. shall be displayed in the hospice Office for public review FAQ as information... First goes to an out-of-network freestanding imaging center for an MRI of knee in support of final.... Involve false claims or Stark violations, a provider handles the refund process will influence the overall. The patient & # x27 ; s state law collection voice now to help CMA explain why must! Credit balances & quot ; ) whether due to claims processing errors overbilling. Occurs, and more these payments to be issued on a timely basis within.! Format of this information will likely vary by insurer insurer to process claims IRS! Fee for a new or renewal application records related to subdivisions 1 through 4 [ above ] Family,! Amounts due to claims processing errors or overbilling is a non-negotiable one time plan a for. Fee for a check, there is no reason you cant issue every refund electronically patients at one plan... Law 2019-191 updated and modernized several provisions of Chapter 90 that pertain the! The amount paid by the SCC will choose the arbitrator & Co. all rights reserved.Privacy StatementTerms of Map... Does exist, the SCC and to the non-initiatingparty is Also required to have specific... Patients at one time plan a schedule for completion that pertain to the non-initiatingparty copy!

Aqua Finance Lawsuit, Jayal Verrez Coconut Oil Video, Articles P